You signed the agreement. The money arrived. The transaction closed.
It is natural to think the hard part is over.
But closing does not necessarily eliminate your financial or contractual risk.
An earnout can fall short. A buyer can default on a seller note. Escrowed funds can be subject to claims. A post-closing adjustment can reduce your proceeds. A personal guarantee may remain in place. Rollover equity can lose value. And employment or transition obligations can continue after you no longer own the business.
These risks are different, but they have one thing in common: they can affect what you receive, what you keep, or what you remain responsible for after closing.
That means evaluating an offer requires looking beyond the headline purchase price.
Ask not only, "What is the purchase price?" but also:
"How much will I receive at closing?"
"What remains at risk after closing?"
"What obligations will continue?"
And, ultimately, "How much of that value will I actually receive and keep?"
The answers can change how you compare offers, negotiate your deal, and structure protections before closing.
Many of the protections against post-closing risk need to be negotiated before you sign the purchase agreement.
|
“Closing is an important milestone, but it is not always the end of the seller’s risk. If part of your consideration is deferred, contingent, held in escrow, or reinvested, you need to understand exactly what could affect your ability to receive or retain that value and what impact you could have on achievement.” – Nicole Kiriakopoulos, Director |
Post-closing risks can include delayed payments, buyer credit risk, indemnification claims, purchase price adjustments, unreleased guarantees, investment risk associated with rollover equity, and continuing employment or consulting obligations.
Some of these risks are unavoidable parts of a negotiated transaction. The goal is not necessarily to eliminate every one of them. The goal is to understand which risks you are accepting and whether you are being compensated appropriately for taking them.
This is why comparing two offers solely by headline price can be misleading.
Consider two hypothetical offers for your company.
Buyer B technically offered more. But $10 million of the consideration remains exposed to future events.
You should evaluate both the amount and the certainty of your proceeds.
For a deeper look at how purchase price becomes cash available to you, see PCE’s guide to calculating net proceeds from a business sale.
An earnout gives you the opportunity to receive additional purchase price after closing if the business meets agreed performance targets. The risk is that you may no longer control many of the decisions that determine whether those targets are achieved.
That tension is one of the most important things to understand about an earnout.
Before the sale, you may control hiring, pricing, capital spending, sales strategy, customer decisions, and operating expenses. After closing, the buyer may control some or all of them.
Suppose $4 million of your purchase price depends on reaching an EBITDA target over the next two years. If the buyer increases corporate expenses allocated to your division, changes the sales strategy, combines facilities, or makes an acquisition that changes how costs are allocated, reported EBITDA may look very different from what you expected when you negotiated the earnout.
The question is not simply whether the target seems achievable today.
You also need to ask:
These issues should be addressed in your transaction documents before closing.
An earnout can help bridge a valuation gap between you and the buyer. But you should not treat contingent consideration as if it were cash already in your account.
If you accept a seller note, you are not just selling your business. You are also financing part of the buyer’s acquisition.
For you, that means buyer creditworthiness matters.
A $5 million seller note is only worth $5 million if the buyer ultimately makes the required payments.
You should understand:
There are also tax considerations when payments are received after the year of sale. The IRS Publication 537 guidance on installment sales explains that certain qualifying transactions may recognize portions of gain as payments are received, while different rules can apply depending on the assets sold and the structure of the transaction.
That does not mean a seller note is necessarily unattractive. A note may help you reach an acceptable value, generate interest income, or make a transaction possible when the buyer cannot fund the entire price at closing.
But a seller note should be evaluated as a credit investment with consideration given to the time value of money, not simply another line in the purchase price.
Your tax advisor and transaction counsel should evaluate the specific consequences and protections based on your deal.
Yes. Your purchase agreement may allow the buyer to pursue certain claims after closing if specified representations, warranties, or covenants prove inaccurate or are breached.
The exact exposure depends on your agreement.
For example, you may have made representations about:
Your agreement may establish limits on claims through baskets, deductibles, caps, survival periods, escrows, and other negotiated terms.
This is why an escrow should not automatically be viewed as cash you have already received. The funds may be designated for potential claims during an agreed period.
The practical question is how much of your consideration remains exposed, for how long, and under what circumstances.
You should also understand the mechanics of the escrow account and whether the buyer can recover from escrow only, pursue you directly, or offset a claim against other payments such as an earnout or seller note.
PCE’s overview of key terms in purchase agreements provides additional context on indemnification provisions, baskets, caps, escrow, and related transaction terms.
The stronger your understanding before signing, the fewer surprises you should face when a claim arrives six or twelve months after closing.
Yes. Many transactions include post-closing purchase price adjustments, often tied to working capital, cash, debt, or other specifically defined balance sheet items.
The concept sounds straightforward. The actual calculation can be anything but straightforward.
Suppose you agree to deliver $4 million of normalized working capital at closing. The buyer later calculates that you delivered only $3.5 million.
That $500,000 difference could reduce your final proceeds.
The dispute may center on questions such as:
Small differences in definitions can produce large dollar differences.
Post-closing adjustments can also have tax implications in some asset transactions. The IRS instructions for Form 8594 explain that certain increases or decreases in consideration after an applicable asset acquisition can require the parties to reallocate consideration and file supplemental reporting.
What matters here is consistency. The definitions, accounting principles, examples, and dispute process should be as clear as possible before closing. A purchase agreement exhibit that illustrates how each post-closing adjustment is calculated can help reduce ambiguity and prevent disputes.
Do not assume that selling the company automatically releases every personal guarantee you signed while you owned it.
Over the years, you may have guaranteed obligations involving:
If those guarantees remain in effect after the sale, you may continue to have personal exposure even though you no longer control the company that created the obligation.
A purchase agreement requiring the buyer to assume an obligation may not, by itself, release you from a separate commitment you made to a lender, landlord, or other third party. The actual result depends on the documents and applicable law.
Before closing, build a complete list of personal guarantees and determine what is required to obtain a written release from each applicable party.
Do not leave this exercise until after ownership changes hands. This is best handled pre-closing in the purchase agreement so any post-closing liabilities remaining with the seller are well understood.
The important question is simple: “After closing, is there any circumstance in which someone can still pursue me personally for an obligation of the business?”
Have your legal advisors answer that question before you sign.
Rollover equity gives you the opportunity to participate in the future value of the business after the transaction. It also means part of your sale proceeds remains invested and at risk.
If you sell to a private equity-backed platform, for example, you may receive cash for most of your ownership while reinvesting a portion into the new company.
That can be attractive. If the combined business grows and is sold later at a higher value, your rollover investment may produce an additional return.
But you are no longer evaluating your own business alone.
You need to understand:
The SEC notes that private equity investments typically involve illiquid private companies, and private equity sponsors commonly take controlling interests in portfolio companies. That matters if your rollover leaves you as a minority investor after the sale. See the SEC’s overview of private equity fund structures and investments.
For you, the biggest change may be control. You can have meaningful money invested in a company while having far less authority over operating and strategic decisions than you had before the transaction.
Read PCE’s key considerations in an equity rollover for a deeper discussion of rollover structure.
Your business may be sold, but your involvement may not end on closing day.
A buyer may ask you to remain as an employee, consultant, board member, or transition advisor. That arrangement can help preserve customer relationships, transfer institutional knowledge, and support a smooth ownership transition.
The risk is assuming the arrangement will be informal because you already know the company.
Your responsibilities after closing should be clear.
Consider:
This area can become especially difficult when you still feel responsible for the company but no longer have final control.
If you are staying after closing, treat your employment or consulting arrangement as a separate economic and personal decision. Do not assume that because the purchase price is attractive, the transition terms will also work for you.
In a recent transaction, PCE’s seller client chose the highest headline price. Included with that offer was a 25% equity rollover and $5 million earnout on a $20 million total transaction value. This left the client with a significant amount tied to the performance of both the client’s company and the private equity platform.
The seller and its PCE banker evaluated the buyer’s stability, the seller’s role after closing, and the mechanics of the earnout. Because the seller was expected to remain with the business after closing, the employment agreement needed to clearly address the seller’s responsibilities, performance goals, compensation, and how any salary changes would affect EBITDA and the earnout calculation
Because so much of the total purchase price was tied to future performance, the purchase agreement needed to clearly define the timing of the working capital true-up, the mechanics of the adjustment calculation, and how EBITDA would be calculated after closing. In some transactions, it may be appropriate to calculate EBITDA both consistently with the company’s historical methodology and in a way that reflects changes the buyer makes to operations or financial reporting.
You reduce post-closing risk by identifying every part of the transaction that remains contingent, deferred, disputed, or dependent on another party after closing.
Before signing, create a simple schedule of your consideration.
|
Consideration |
Amount |
Timing |
What Could Reduce It? |
|
Cash at closing |
$ |
Closing |
Closing adjustments |
|
Escrow or holdback |
$ |
Future release |
Indemnification claims or other items depending on agreement. |
|
Seller note |
$ |
Scheduled payments |
Buyer default |
|
Earnout |
$ |
Future period |
Performance or calculation mechanics, ie changes in financial reporting |
|
Rollover equity |
$ |
Future liquidity event |
Business performance and dilution |
Then ask a second set of questions about your obligations.
These questions may change how you negotiate price.
You might decide that $1 of cash at closing is worth more to you than $1 of potential earnout consideration. You may accept a lower headline value in exchange for more certainty. Or you may accept more deferred consideration because you believe the opportunity justifies the additional risk.
There is no single structure that is right for every seller.
The important part is making the tradeoff intentionally.
When you sell the company you spent years building, it is easy to focus on one number: the purchase price.
But the structure around that number can be just as important.
A strong offer should be evaluated based on when you get paid, what remains at risk, what obligations survive, how much control you retain, and what protections you have if something goes wrong.
Many of those decisions become difficult to change once the purchase agreement is signed.
Before accepting a deal structure, understand not only the headline purchase price, but also how much consideration you will receive at closing, what could reduce your proceeds, and which obligations may follow you after the transaction.
If you are evaluating a potential sale, PCE Investment Bankers can help you compare offers and understand how transaction structure affects the certainty and timing of your proceeds.
Risks after selling your business may include earnout shortfalls, buyer default on seller financing, indemnification claims, escrow exposure, purchase price adjustments, rollover equity losses, unreleased personal guarantees, and continuing employment or consulting obligations. Which risks apply to you depends on your transaction structure and purchase agreement.
How long you remain liable depends on your transaction documents and the specific obligation or claim involved. Different representations, covenants, indemnification obligations, guarantees, and other provisions can have different survival periods. Your transaction counsel should identify each obligation that continues after closing, when it expires, and whether representation and warranty insurance may help reduce certain post-closing exposure What happens if a buyer does not pay your earnout?
Your options depend on the earnout provisions in your purchase agreement. The agreement should define how the earnout is calculated, what information you can access, how disagreements are handled, and what remedies are available. Because you may have limited operating control after closing, these protections should be negotiated before the transaction closes.
Your remedies depend on the seller note, security documents, subordination terms, guarantees, and other agreements. A secured note or guarantee may provide different protections than an unsecured obligation, but no structure removes credit risk completely. Evaluate the buyer’s ability to repay before treating the note as equivalent to cash.
Yes, a buyer may be able to make certain claims after closing if permitted by the purchase agreement. Claims often relate to representations, warranties, covenants, taxes, or specifically identified liabilities. Your agreement should establish the scope, limitations, procedures, and survival periods that apply.
A personal guarantee may continue unless the party benefiting from that guarantee formally releases you. Do not assume that the buyer’s assumption of a company obligation automatically terminates your separate guarantee. Identify your guarantees before closing and work with legal counsel to obtain appropriate written releases.
Rollover equity generally carries more uncertainty than cash at closing because its future value depends on the performance, financing, governance, and eventual liquidity of the post-transaction company. It may provide meaningful upside, but you should evaluate it as a new investment rather than simply treating it as cash consideration.
You should evaluate post-closing risks before signing the purchase agreement, and ideally while comparing initial offers and negotiating the letter of intent. Once major economic terms are agreed upon, your negotiating flexibility may decrease. Identifying deferred consideration, continuing obligations, guarantees, and potential claims early gives you more opportunity to address them in the transaction structure.
Nicole Kiriakopoulos
Nicole Kiriakopoulos is a Director at PCE, supporting clients through buy-side and sell-side M&A transactions. With nearly 20 years of experience and a focus on facility services, she has advised on more than 100 deals totaling over $1 billion in value.